Hotel Newton

Overall:

"I would stay there again, althought I would not get the one bedroom efficiency studio." — source Orbitz

Clean:

"Clean, but unimpressive entrance and small lobby did not prepare me for a perfectly appointed and newly refurbished room." — source Orbitz

"This is a hotel that reminds me of the pensionne-type hotels I stayed while in Europe--small lobby, old elevator, but the room was large and well-equipped and clean, with a good-sized private bath, and even though the beds were sort of hard and pillows small, it was no big deal for my family." — source Hotels.com

"Our room was very clean and spacious, but do not expect great window view since some of the rooms may overlook at the inner side of the block." — source Expedia

"The room was clean, and the staff friendly." — source Orbitz

"The room was small, but very clean." — source Orbitz

Location:

"The location of this hotel for the relatively cheap price can't be beat. There's a subway stop that takes you almost directly to any part of the city located less than a block away." — source Hotels.com

"Great location near subway, Central Park and Riverside Park and lots of reasonably priced restaurants." — source Hotels.com

"This newly renovated hotel is perfectly located for travelers who are fond of the Upper West Side, or would like to become familiar with these neighborhoods." — source Expedia

"The location is perfect for getting around uptown or jumping on the subway down the street." — source Expedia

"Very good location and 1 min walk to the 1,2 or 3 subway line." — source Hotels.com

Value:

"Stayed here during a family vacation to NYC and everything I had heard about this hotel was true: small rooms, great location, great price." — source Hotels.com

"I needed a place to stay one night near Columbia University, and Hotel Newton was reasonably priced and reasonably close." — source Expedia

"For the price, you canÂ’t beat it." — source Expedia

Room:

"We opted for the room with the private bathroom. The room was smaller compared to other hotels I've stayed in NYC." — source Hotels.com

"The room consisted of everything I need like a microwave and refrigerator. My room was very hot though and smelled weird." — source Expedia

"The rooms are a bit small and ours was a bit shabby and smelly." — source Expedia