The Waldorf-astoria

Overall:

"Great hotel with lots of history." — source Skoosh

"Room was small & somewhat dated for the price, but perfect mid-town location, top-notch service, classically beautiful hotel." — source Orbitz

"The overall beaty of the lobbies upon arriving is worth the price of any room." — source Hotels.com

"Wonderful hotel with fabulous staff and fascinating story." — source Hotels.com

"Overall I would not recommend to anyone." — source Priceline

Clean:

"Room was very clean and spacious." — source Hotels.com

"The room was very clean and well maintained with rich, classic furnishings, the bedding was extremely comfortable with exceptional linens, and the temperature of room easy to control and working well." — source Travelocity

"When requesting another room I was informed it was "An old hotel" as my friend said then charge 1950's prices because that's the last time anyone cleaned the curtians." — source Travelocity

"We were treated with rudeness and condescension at check-in and given a room with no view, offensive cleaning smells, and a small bathroom with no bathrobes provided." — source Travelocity

"\nAfter the first night, I had left a note in the room for the cleaning attendant pointing out the beard of dust on the baseboards." — source Travelocity

Service:

"Yes, the check-in line is long and the lobby can resemble a commuter depot, but this is a beautiful old hotel and we had outstanding service despite the crowds (hotel was completely full)." — source Skoosh

"The service was impeccable and we loved the old world charm of the hotel." — source Hotels.com

"Great location, friendly staff, beautiful facilities." — source Priceline

"Our disapointments were related to the plumbing, the hvac (was on heat only and the room was hot, we were able to open our window and get relief, night turn down only happened on the first night, as well as newspaper only on the first morning) All that said, it was a great experience in a great hotel with great service and amenities in the heart of New York." — source Travelocity

"The only issue is that there is no wireless service in the rooms." — source Expedia

Location:

"Location was perfect, within walking distance to majority of attractions and shopping area." — source Orbitz

"The location was great it was walking distance to times square." — source Skoosh

"Great price and very good location." — source Hotels.com

"First, valet parking is very hard to locate and with Park Ave traffic, we waited almost an hour to park." — source Travelocity

"I enjoyed my stay at this hotel; the staff were nice, check-in and out was easy, the room were neatly made and the hotel is located to so many attractions." — source Expedia

Value:

"the staff was amazing great price,even better hotel." — source Priceline

"I stayed in a Luxury Suite at the cost of a standard room at most hotels in the area." — source Travelocity

"I was billed $94 dollars." — source Expedia

"The upgrade included breakfast for two that we valued at $50 a person." — source Travelocity

"Other than that, the stay was fairly unremarkable for the price paid." — source Expedia