The Algonquin

Overall:

"Atmosphere is great at hotel." — source Hotels.com

"The cozy lobby bar is a great place to defrost on the cold winter nights and then grab an apple from the front desk for a snack on the way to your room." — source Travelocity

"We had stopped by the Algonquin Hotel bar, The Blue Bar last month and had such a great experience there, that we decided to travel to New York again in August for an overnight and chose the Algonquin." — source Expedia

"We will definitely go back here and recommend it to anyone who wants a clean, friendly, and conveniently located place to stay while exploring NY." — source Travelocity

"I would definitely stay there again." — source Expedia

Clean:

"room was clean, nice deep bathtub to take a bath in, shower had great water pressure and warm water, LCD flatscreen tv with like 40 channels, free Wifi in room, friendly staff, good food." — source Travelocity

"If you are looking for a Hotel in the middle of Manhattan that is squeaky clean, full of great customer service and an aura of New York in the good ole days, look no further." — source Travelocity

"The staff were very nice and the room was clean." — source Expedia

"The room was clean, quiet and comfortable." — source Expedia

"The location was good and the room clean, but the very old bathroom and closet size room left me distrusting online travel website ratings and descriptions." — source Travelocity

Service:

"The only complaint I have is that room service closes at 10:30 on Sunday nights." — source Skoosh

"And the service was good on some fronts but I did not get ice when I requested and the front desk staff seemed quite inexperienced and was unable to answer questions about the business center (there's a charge to use internet) or the message system." — source Hotels.com

"Great location, friendly, helpful staff, clean rooms, great cleaing staff, loved the hotel cat Mathilda, highly recommended." — source Travelocity

"Morning room service for coffee was quick. Between 5th and 6th Avenues on 44 St, hotel is 4- to 5-block walk to hop-on, hop-off bus tour services and Rockefeller Center." — source Travelocity

"The lobby is just beautiful, great old vibe, we had dinner and drinks there one night and the food and service was great, as well as having live music in the oak room." — source Travelocity

Location:

"The Algonquin Hotel, located within easy walking distance to Times Square and other main attractions in NYC, offered a warm, personal, surprisingly quiet and inviting atmosphere to our trip." — source Travelocity

"Its in a great location and I definately will be back." — source Expedia

"This hotel was great -- the room was nice, the bed was comfortable and the location was fantastic but they were doing construction next door and the construction noise during the day was terrible." — source Travelocity

"Which leads me to the best part of this hotel; the location. It was within easy walking distance to many of the Broadway theaters, the Tkts booth, shopping, the subway, etc." — source Travelocity

"Location is PERFECT, between 5th ave shops and 6th ave (easy walking to Rockefeller Plaza, Radio City, Gray Line double decker bus office)." — source Travelocity

Value:

"Bar and lounge, nice and cozy, manhattans, bass on tap, sliders, expensive there, but great deal on room, nice king size bed, very comfortable, noise from construction started after 8 am, but we were up by then, so no problem." — source Travelocity

"If you're looking for a great NY experience without a huge price this is perfect - 4 star hotel without the pricetag." — source Travelocity

"I got a great deal via travelocity for 254 a night which was (for New York) an incredible deal." — source Travelocity

"The only downsides we experienced at The Algonquin were the concierge and the cost of room service." — source Travelocity

"The Algonquin had always been out of my price range, but this time I was lucky." — source Travelocity