Value Key West Hotels

"Overall a very splendid hotel and a comfortable stay." — source Orbitz

"Tiki bar needs to stay open longer and the A/C was a little loud, but would stay again in a heartbeat." — source Travelocity

"Overall we loved the place and the staff who took time to visit, briefly, were super." — source Hotels.com

"Would not stay again, staff very rude to us several times and we can't understand why." — source Travelocity

"nice hotel a bit on the high side service was good rooms were nice plenty of room not far from all the shops would stay there again." — source Hotels.com

"about 5 blocks from duval street great distance for renting a scooter (make sure you look around to get the cheapest rate for scooters) over all had a great time will most definitly stay there again." — source Travelocity

"Would I Recommend This Hotel." — source Orbitz

"The only thing I could really complain about is the carpet was dirty but other than that for the price we will stay again." — source Hotels.com

"The pool area was a great place to relax so it didn't matter there was no balcony or view." — source Orbitz

"This "hotel" appears to be a time-share that has wonderful potential as a hidden gem, but has some serious work to do." — source Hotels.com

"I loved the Island City House - the buildings were charming, the staff was friendly and helpful, loved all the cats, and my room was lovely and very clean." — source Travelocity

"Hotel located in a great spot, close enough to walk to most places, yet far enough away to be a great peacful retreat." — source Orbitz

"Overall I would stay at this hotel again." — source Orbitz

"I asked if she recommended any specific, since I wanted everything perfect considering we were getting married, she said they are all nice and much less expensive then the big hotels." — source Travelocity

"" Although the room was very nice, the poor service ruined our stay and affected our overall rating of the hotel." — source Hotels.com

"Would not recommend this hotel to anyone." — source Priceline

"The pool is heated and would be wonderful in cooler weather but was slightly too warm for the 100 degree heat although I still got in :) Great hotel, very friendly staff, great lighthouse view." — source Orbitz

"I was pleased with the overall location of the Hotel." — source Orbitz

"I would recommend this hotel to other couples and plan on returning one day." — source Orbitz

"It was great location/Great customer service/Met some great people/very relaxing evening with beautiful breeze going through the palm trees." — source Travelocity